- Enjoy this article? Help vote it up the 'Vine.
- Public Discussion (27)
ignorance is so sad.
- 9 votes
Clearly we need to add more Language and Culture classes in our schools. Ignorance is not a good excuse and it is sad it has become all to common.
- 5 votes
Too bad I wasn't there as I was when I went a catholic high school. Both teachers would have been shredded and humiliated beyond belief.
That was one of my ways of entertaining myself in high school, savaging morons who claimed to be teachers.
- 5 votes
This is completely ridiculous!
Clipping to my column, and some of my groups as well.
- 6 votes
Good post monkeyman. Thanks for bringing this outrage to nv for everyone to see...I can only say that it does not surprise me. A Catholic School that is 60% NA being sujected to this nonsense. Reminds me of the ''Indian Boarding Schools'' that they ran.
Clipping to other groups.
- 11 votes
Too typical of such schools. Fully prepared to believe the worst of students instead of having enough sense to realize that there occasionally unfortunate-sounding words in other languages that are innocent of the meaning their sound alikes have in another language. The Menominee for "hello" apparently sounds like a rude English word for the female naughty bits. The Polish for "grandmother" sounds a lot like the rude Spanish word for what this idiot teacher thought was being said. I knew a cook who spoke excellent English, beaten into her by the sisters at her school, but she knew that her Spanish (her native tongue) was weak because they didn't bother teaching that. Things haven't changed in diocese schools yet, just like the rapine behavior of priests retains the winking okay of the church hierarchy.
The Washinawatok family should not expect much in terms of owning responsibility nor genuine remorse on the part of the school and the teachers & principal involved. They've decided, wrong or not, that Miranda is a troublemaker, so no real apology will ever materialize, never mind any reparation or change of attitudes and policies.
- 6 votes
WTH !! This is blatant prejudice as far as I'm concerned. This girl deserves a lot more than a lame apology! (what, I don't know, these actions can't be taken back)
- 10 votes
Perhaps they thought she said something else instead and misinterpreted it which does happen quite often. However it is a bit ridiculous on how many natives are in the school. School will be hurting if it is true.
off-topic: Like the avatar monkeyman perhaps next year we can win it all.
- 3 votes
Had nothing to do with what they "thought" she said. It had to do with the fact that she is Native American. If she had been Hispanic it would have been overlooked; they wouldn't have dared make an issue of it.
- 3 votes
My grandmother used to say that a person lacking education but endowed with common sense is a better asset than an educated idiot. She was right.
- 14 votes
"It is a thousand times better to have common sense without education than to have education without common sense." - Robert Green Ingersoll
- 8 votes
True. I have been around brilliant PHD's with and without common sense. Well said Shub.
- 5 votes
I am really surprised (and yet not surprised) that this kind of bs is still going on re suppression of Native American languages is concerned.
- 6 votes
We're talking Native Americans and Catholics - story has been going of for over 300 years when the "Colonials" thought the Catholic church could teach the Natives better than their own people and SAVE them from their heathenistic savage ways.
Let's do the same to the Blacks, Hispanics, Asians and Whites and see what kind of RAPID APOLOGY would be forth coming.
- 5 votes
Such an over reaction by these teachers. Native languages are dying out due to this type of horrible behavior. I applaud this little girl's mother for keeping their language alive for another generation and her hands on parenting. These teachers and school need to clean up their act and get a grip.
- 5 votes
In important to keep every language and culture alive. To much is lost when a language dies.
- 5 votes
Fantastic find monkeyman, great seed indeed.
This is wrong on every count, period. The teacher should be suspended for losing her cool with students. And the other teacher should be told point blank to in the future mind her own damn business.
It's a sad day in America when things get to this point to say the least.
- 5 votes
The languages of the planet should be embraced not maligned or discouraged. Too many are so uppity about everyone speaking "English" and cannot or will not tolerate any other native language. When I hear someone conversing in their native tongue that is different from my English I hear a melody of exchange. Why be intimidated when we can learn from each other. My son taught me the Hawaiian language when he was going to school on the island. Sure, I mucked it up frequently and he'd laugh and keep assisting me. He speaks Japanese and has taught me. My daughter learn Vietnamese to converse with her classmates parents while in Kindergarten. Instead of rejecting other's language why aren't we embracing this and making an attempt to learn for ourselves?
Thankfully the schools where I worked were very good with the students with English as a Second Language. Sure most of the children latched on to English swear words and slang but we simply asked them not to swear in school. Making a big deal out of children conversing with one another in any language was not an issue for us.
The teachers of this school should be reprimanded for their shortsightedness. Their actions are totally uncalled for. We must not lose any of the languages of this planet as they are sacred and must be remembered and spoken.
- 3 votes
I wish I spoke more than English and a bit of German. (I can manage Hello, Goodbye, Please, Thank you, and Yo' Mama in about six others, but it's not much to build a convesation on.)
There are too many ugly Americans who ridicule those who learn English as a 2nd language for making mistakes, and condemn those who do not learn English as a 2nd language for being too isolationist or nationalist, even when those people aren't intending to stay in the U.S. or are those the ugly Yanks have met when traveling overseas. These uppity Americans never seem to see the irony in that many of them are barely fluent in their own language.
- 5 votes
Amen to that, James! I was attempting to teach a wee Hispanic boy English and he was very shy and hesitant to make any attempt at speaking the language. I truly understood where he was coming from. We, along, with a classmate of his that was also Hispanic were reading Charlotte's Web in both English and Spanish. After the second day of encouraging this young man I thought I'd try something in hope it would be the motivation to make an effort on his part. I took his Spanish version of the story and began reading it out loud. Both children became wide eyed and tried for a moment to hide their amusement. I kept on reading and struggled to keep a sincere straight face. Finally they couldn't hold back any longer and rolled with laughter. My experiment worked as my little buddy cooperated beautifully from then on.
- 3 votes
two Thursdays ago this very beautiful 7th grader was suspended for one basketball game (in which she was a member) because she spoke Menominee to a fellow classmate during class. Tragic that one cannot speak another language in the US. What happened to freedom of Speech?
I am a little Aghast that they not only gave her complete name but also have a picture of her. I have major concerns regarding placing a 7th grader's picture and full name on the internet.
After all... it is the "World Wide Web"
- 4 votes
Apparently protection of minors is completely foreign to this school, as it is to their masters, even in cases like this. Whichever paper, radio or tv station first destroyed her privacy should be reprimanded too.
- 1 vote
Since the first settlement in Jamestown, over 400 years ago; the religious, pompus white people have tried to wipe out the Native American Indian speach, spirituality, and way of life. Thankfully, they have still not succeeded. Every student, with Native American ancestry, should boycott this school. Chances are, they are receiving USA Federal funding for having Native American Indian enrollment, which should be yanked also. The tribes need to use what the white people value the most to fight the abolishing of Native American Indians...money and property. The greatest honor we give our native ancestors is the insistence that we survive as a people, keeping our language, beliefs, and governance alive.
- 2 votes
Truly disgusting, but not unprecedented nor surprising! They may be trained and educated enough to be teachers, but they are ignorant! Will this type of attitude EVER change? 200 years and we are still having to deal with stupidity!
Nookomis ♥
- 3 votes
You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead. |



